{
    "ok": true,
    "pcie_version": "1.28.0",
    "requested_query": "Define Aging in humans",
    "executed_query": "Define Aging in humans",
    "query_passthrough": true,
    "answer": "I found relevant evidence for “Human Aging”, but I could not ground a sufficiently verified direct definition in the accepted evidence. I will not construct a definition by combining separate word meanings. No knowledge was created.\n\nValidation: Partially validated\nConfidence: 62%\nProgenitor found credible supporting evidence, but independent validation was incomplete.\nHighest-confidence web evidence:\n- Human - Wikipedia — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human\n- HUMAN Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster — https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/human\n- Human body | Organs, Systems, Structure, Diagram, & Facts - Britannica — https://www.britannica.com/science/human-body",
    "research_context": {
        "original_query": "Define Aging in humans",
        "normalized_query": "What is Human Aging?",
        "resolved_topic": "Human Aging",
        "transport_version": "1.33.0",
        "semantic_frame": {
            "raw_query": "Define Aging in humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "concept": "Aging",
            "context": "humans",
            "context_preposition": "in",
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "research_query": "What is Human Aging?",
            "confidence": 0.96,
            "flags": [],
            "intent_family": "information",
            "intent_arguments": [],
            "semantic_roles": [],
            "intent_graph": {
                "primary_intent": "DEFINE",
                "nodes": [
                    {
                        "id": "intent_1",
                        "text": "Define Aging in humans",
                        "intent": "DEFINE",
                        "family": "information",
                        "confidence": 0.94,
                        "arguments": [],
                        "secondary_intents": [],
                        "depends_on": []
                    }
                ],
                "edges": [],
                "multi_intent": false,
                "requires_prior_context": false,
                "graph_version": "1.28.0"
            },
            "parser_version": "1.33.0"
        },
        "intent_research_envelope": {
            "version": "1.33.0",
            "original_query": "Define Aging in humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "intent_family": "information",
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "semantic_roles": [],
            "phenomenon": "",
            "subject": "",
            "predicate": "",
            "effect": "",
            "candidate_causes": [],
            "evidence_goal": "",
            "relationship_locked": false,
            "composition_allowed": true,
            "immutable": true
        },
        "semantic_envelope": {
            "version": "1.33.0",
            "original_query": "Define Aging in humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "concept": "Aging",
            "context": "humans",
            "context_preposition": "in",
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "canonical_aliases": [
                "Human Aging",
                "Aging in humans",
                "Aging in human beings",
                "human biological Aging",
                "biological Aging in humans",
                "Human ageing",
                "ageing in humans",
                "ageing in human beings",
                "human biological ageing",
                "biological ageing in humans",
                "senescence in humans",
                "human senescence"
            ],
            "required_domains": [
                "human_biology"
            ],
            "domain_keywords": [
                "human",
                "humans",
                "biological",
                "biology",
                "physiology",
                "organism",
                "species"
            ],
            "forbidden_senses": [
                "entertainment",
                "gaming",
                "unrelated_proper_noun",
                "fictional_character",
                "game_mechanic",
                "song",
                "film",
                "tv_series"
            ],
            "parser_confidence": 0.96,
            "immutable": true
        },
        "evidence_semantic_frame": {
            "raw_query": "Define Aging in humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "concept": "Aging",
            "context": "humans",
            "context_preposition": "in",
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "research_query": "What is Human Aging?",
            "confidence": 0.96,
            "flags": [],
            "intent_family": "information",
            "intent_arguments": [],
            "semantic_roles": [],
            "intent_graph": {
                "primary_intent": "DEFINE",
                "nodes": [
                    {
                        "id": "intent_1",
                        "text": "Define Aging in humans",
                        "intent": "DEFINE",
                        "family": "information",
                        "confidence": 0.94,
                        "arguments": [],
                        "secondary_intents": [],
                        "depends_on": []
                    }
                ],
                "edges": [],
                "multi_intent": false,
                "requires_prior_context": false,
                "graph_version": "1.28.0"
            },
            "parser_version": "1.33.0"
        },
        "context_locked_search_queries": [
            "\"Human Aging\"",
            "Human Aging",
            "Human Aging definition",
            "Human Aging meaning",
            "Aging in humans",
            "Human Aging human",
            "Human Aging humans",
            "Human Aging biological",
            "Human Aging biology",
            "Human Aging physiology"
        ]
    },
    "research_transport": {
        "status": "PASS",
        "resolved_topic": "Human Aging",
        "search_queries": [
            "\"Human Aging\"",
            "Human Aging",
            "Human Aging definition",
            "Human Aging meaning",
            "Aging in humans",
            "Human Aging human",
            "Human Aging humans",
            "Human Aging biological",
            "Human Aging biology",
            "Human Aging physiology"
        ],
        "provider_queries": [
            {
                "provider": "bingRss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "raw_count": 8,
                "relevant_count": 3,
                "rejected_count": 5,
                "effective_url": "https://www.bing.com/search?format=rss&count=10&setlang=en-US&cc=US&q=%22Human%20Aging%22&pciecb=335a9c7b5eda"
            },
            {
                "provider": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "raw_count": 8,
                "relevant_count": 3,
                "rejected_count": 5,
                "effective_url": "https://www.bing.com/search?count=10&setlang=en-US&q=%22Human%20Aging%22&pciecb=2d73fc0fef2e"
            }
        ],
        "provider_rejected_count": 10,
        "provider_rejected": [
            {
                "engine": "bing_rss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Humana | Find Medicare Plans and Health Insurance Coverage",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.4182
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing_rss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Human Benchmark",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing_rss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Humana",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.4732
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing_rss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Rag'n'Bone Man - Human (Official Video) - YouTube",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing_rss",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Rag'n'Bone Man - Human (Lyrics) - YouTube",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Humana | Find Medicare Plans and Health Insurance Coverage",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.4182
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Human Benchmark",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Humana",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.4732
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Rag'n'Bone Man - Human (Official Video) - YouTube",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            },
            {
                "engine": "bing",
                "query": "\"Human Aging\"",
                "title": "Rag'n'Bone Man - Human (Lyrics) - YouTube",
                "reason": "open_world_evidence_score_below_threshold",
                "score": 0.5317
            }
        ],
        "raw_results_count": 6,
        "accepted_results_count": 6,
        "rejected_results_count": 0,
        "provider_errors": [],
        "rejection_reasons": [],
        "top_evidence_scores": [
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66
        ],
        "open_world_admission": true,
        "semantic_sense_rejections": 0,
        "semantic_sense_diagnostics": [],
        "context_locked_search_queries": [
            "\"Human Aging\"",
            "Human Aging",
            "Human Aging definition",
            "Human Aging meaning",
            "Aging in humans",
            "Human Aging human",
            "Human Aging humans",
            "Human Aging biological",
            "Human Aging biology",
            "Human Aging physiology"
        ]
    },
    "rag": {
        "version": "1.33.0",
        "normalized_query": "What is Human Aging?",
        "entity": "Human Aging",
        "entity_type": "public_entity_or_topic",
        "entity_resolution": {
            "entity": "Human Aging",
            "entity_type": "public_entity_or_topic",
            "open_world": true,
            "aliases": [
                "Human aging",
                "Human agings",
                "Human Aging",
                "Aging in humans",
                "Aging in human beings",
                "human biological Aging",
                "biological Aging in humans",
                "Human ageing",
                "ageing in humans",
                "ageing in human beings",
                "human biological ageing",
                "biological ageing in humans",
                "senescence in humans",
                "human senescence"
            ],
            "confidence": 1,
            "source": "persistent_research_envelope"
        },
        "accepted_chunks": 6,
        "rejected_chunks": 0,
        "cross_entity_rejections": 0,
        "rejection_reasons": [],
        "top_evidence_scores": [
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66,
            0.66
        ],
        "open_world_admission": true,
        "semantic_sense_rejections": 0,
        "semantic_sense_diagnostics": [],
        "answer_grounding": {
            "supported_sentences": 4,
            "unsupported_sentences": 0,
            "grounded": true
        },
        "pipeline": [
            "canonical_context",
            "semantic_alias_expansion",
            "retrieve",
            "chunk",
            "semantic_topic_admission",
            "definition_evidence_matching",
            "predicate_grounding",
            "snippet_contamination_filter",
            "rank",
            "synthesize",
            "verify",
            "semantic_sense_disambiguation",
            "context_lock"
        ]
    },
    "canonical_concept_research": {
        "attempted": true,
        "improved": false,
        "queries": [
            "\"Human Aging\"",
            "Human Aging definition",
            "\"Aging in humans\"",
            "Aging in humans definition",
            "\"Aging in human beings\"",
            "Aging in human beings definition",
            "\"human biological Aging\"",
            "human biological Aging definition",
            "\"biological Aging in humans\"",
            "biological Aging in humans definition",
            "\"Human ageing\"",
            "Human ageing definition",
            "\"ageing in humans\"",
            "ageing in humans definition"
        ],
        "gate": {
            "direct_concept_evidence": false,
            "status": "DIRECT_CONCEPT_EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT",
            "direct_evidence_count": 0,
            "distinct_direct_sources": 0,
            "best_definition_match": 0,
            "synthesis_verified": true,
            "claim_count": 4,
            "blocks_composition": false
        },
        "canonical_resolution": {
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "aliases": [
                "Human Aging",
                "Aging in humans",
                "Aging in human beings",
                "human biological Aging",
                "biological Aging in humans",
                "Human ageing",
                "ageing in humans",
                "ageing in human beings",
                "human biological ageing",
                "biological ageing in humans",
                "senescence in humans",
                "human senescence"
            ],
            "concept": "Aging",
            "context": "humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "status": "RESOLVED",
            "resolver_version": "1.28.0"
        },
        "gate_after_retry": {
            "direct_concept_evidence": false,
            "status": "DIRECT_CONCEPT_EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT",
            "direct_evidence_count": 0,
            "distinct_direct_sources": 0,
            "best_definition_match": 0,
            "synthesis_verified": true,
            "claim_count": 4,
            "blocks_composition": false
        },
        "raw_results_count": 8,
        "accepted_results_count": 6,
        "final_gate": {
            "direct_concept_evidence": false,
            "status": "DIRECT_CONCEPT_EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT",
            "direct_evidence_count": 0,
            "distinct_direct_sources": 0,
            "best_definition_match": 0,
            "synthesis_verified": true,
            "claim_count": 4,
            "blocks_composition": false
        }
    },
    "research_evidence_diagnostic": {
        "version": "1.28.0",
        "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
        "required_domains": [
            "human_biology"
        ],
        "queries_issued": [
            "\"Human Aging\"",
            "Human Aging",
            "Human Aging definition",
            "Human Aging meaning",
            "Aging in humans",
            "Human Aging human",
            "Human Aging humans",
            "Human Aging biological",
            "Human Aging biology",
            "Human Aging physiology",
            "\"Aging in humans\"",
            "Aging in humans definition",
            "\"Aging in human beings\"",
            "Aging in human beings definition",
            "\"human biological Aging\"",
            "human biological Aging definition",
            "\"biological Aging in humans\"",
            "biological Aging in humans definition",
            "\"Human ageing\"",
            "Human ageing definition",
            "\"ageing in humans\"",
            "ageing in humans definition"
        ],
        "raw_results": 6,
        "accepted_chunks": 6,
        "primary_evidence": 6,
        "semantic_sense_rejections": 0,
        "definition_evidence_count": 0,
        "direct_gate": {
            "direct_concept_evidence": false,
            "status": "DIRECT_CONCEPT_EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT",
            "direct_evidence_count": 0,
            "distinct_direct_sources": 0,
            "best_definition_match": 0,
            "synthesis_verified": true,
            "claim_count": 4,
            "blocks_composition": false
        },
        "synthesis_verified": true,
        "synthesis_claim_count": 4,
        "synthesis_confidence": 0.9395,
        "direct_synthesis_block_reason": "DIRECT_CONCEPT_EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT",
        "rejection_reasons": [],
        "rejected_samples": []
    },
    "synthesis_diagnostic": {
        "version": "1.28.0",
        "composer_used": false,
        "composer_reason": "activation_gate_blocked",
        "activation": {
            "version": "1.28.0",
            "eligible": false,
            "status": "COMPOSER_ACTIVATION_BLOCKED",
            "activation_basis": [
                "grounded_upstream_answer"
            ],
            "reasons": [
                "no_grounded_claim_handoff",
                "explicitly_unresolved_answer"
            ],
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "topic": "Human Aging",
            "input_claim_count": 0,
            "accepted_evidence_count": 6,
            "supported_sentence_count": 4,
            "grounded_upstream": true,
            "direct_concept_evidence": false,
            "upstream_verified": false,
            "policy": "composer activation may use grounded/direct accepted evidence even when upstream synthesis verification is false; evidence admission thresholds remain unchanged"
        },
        "intent": null,
        "topic": null,
        "input_claim_count": 0,
        "candidate_claims": [],
        "selected_claims": [],
        "transformations": [],
        "output_answer": "I found relevant evidence for “Human Aging”, but I could not ground a sufficiently verified direct definition in the accepted evidence. I will not construct a definition by combining separate word meanings. No knowledge was created.",
        "grounding": {
            "supported_sentences": 4,
            "unsupported_sentences": 0,
            "grounded": true
        },
        "upstream_verified": false,
        "upstream_confidence": 0,
        "policy": "accepted evidence -> ranked claims -> intent shape -> grounding verification -> final answer"
    },
    "composer_activation": {
        "version": "1.28.0",
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "COMPOSER_ACTIVATION_BLOCKED",
        "activation_basis": [
            "grounded_upstream_answer"
        ],
        "reasons": [
            "no_grounded_claim_handoff",
            "explicitly_unresolved_answer"
        ],
        "intent": "DEFINE",
        "topic": "Human Aging",
        "input_claim_count": 0,
        "accepted_evidence_count": 6,
        "supported_sentence_count": 4,
        "grounded_upstream": true,
        "direct_concept_evidence": false,
        "upstream_verified": false,
        "policy": "composer activation may use grounded/direct accepted evidence even when upstream synthesis verification is false; evidence admission thresholds remain unchanged"
    },
    "semantic_envelope": {
        "version": "1.33.0",
        "original_query": "Define Aging in humans",
        "intent": "DEFINE",
        "concept": "Aging",
        "context": "humans",
        "context_preposition": "in",
        "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
        "canonical_aliases": [
            "Human Aging",
            "Aging in humans",
            "Aging in human beings",
            "human biological Aging",
            "biological Aging in humans",
            "Human ageing",
            "ageing in humans",
            "ageing in human beings",
            "human biological ageing",
            "biological ageing in humans",
            "senescence in humans",
            "human senescence"
        ],
        "required_domains": [
            "human_biology"
        ],
        "domain_keywords": [
            "human",
            "humans",
            "biological",
            "biology",
            "physiology",
            "organism",
            "species"
        ],
        "forbidden_senses": [
            "entertainment",
            "gaming",
            "unrelated_proper_noun",
            "fictional_character",
            "game_mechanic",
            "song",
            "film",
            "tv_series"
        ],
        "parser_confidence": 0.96,
        "immutable": true
    },
    "compositional_reasoning": {
        "attempted": false,
        "used": false,
        "confidence_class": "DIRECT",
        "components": [],
        "compatibility_gate": null,
        "policy": "direct_context_locked_search_before_composition",
        "semantic_firewall": [],
        "contextual_definition_kill_switch": true,
        "kill_switch_reason": "explicit_context_requires_direct_grounded_evidence"
    },
    "semantic_promotion_gate": {
        "allow": true,
        "status": "SEMANTIC_PROMOTION_APPROVED",
        "reasons": [],
        "original_query": "Define Aging in humans",
        "resolved_topic": "Human Aging",
        "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
        "frame": {
            "raw_query": "Define Aging in humans",
            "intent": "DEFINE",
            "concept": "Aging",
            "context": "humans",
            "context_preposition": "in",
            "canonical_topic": "Human Aging",
            "research_query": "What is Human Aging?",
            "confidence": 0.96,
            "flags": [],
            "intent_family": "information",
            "intent_arguments": [],
            "semantic_roles": [],
            "intent_graph": {
                "primary_intent": "DEFINE",
                "nodes": [
                    {
                        "id": "intent_1",
                        "text": "Define Aging in humans",
                        "intent": "DEFINE",
                        "family": "information",
                        "confidence": 0.94,
                        "arguments": [],
                        "secondary_intents": [],
                        "depends_on": []
                    }
                ],
                "edges": [],
                "multi_intent": false,
                "requires_prior_context": false,
                "graph_version": "1.28.0"
            },
            "parser_version": "1.33.0"
        }
    },
    "verified_memory": {
        "promoted": false,
        "reason": "knowledge_consolidation_not_approved"
    },
    "final_answer_authority": "server_research_service_v1.33.0",
    "elapsed_ms": 2274
}