{
    "ok": true,
    "status": "PASS",
    "version": "1.33.0",
    "mode": "synthetic_causal_consensus_no_web",
    "passed": 8,
    "total": 8,
    "failed": 0,
    "checks": {
        "extracts_relationship_claims": true,
        "cross_source_consensus": true,
        "good_evidence_answer_sufficient": true,
        "composer_used": true,
        "answer_mentions_oxygen": true,
        "answer_mentions_moisture_or_water": true,
        "answer_gate_allows": true,
        "weak_evidence_not_sufficient": true
    },
    "good": {
        "claims": [
            {
                "text": "Iron corrosion requires moisture and oxygen and produces iron oxides commonly associated with rust.",
                "source_title": "Materials",
                "source_url": "https://example.gov/corrosion",
                "source_domain": "example.gov",
                "evidence_score": 0.88,
                "relationship_score": 1,
                "relationship_types": [
                    "effect",
                    "mechanism",
                    "condition"
                ],
                "subject_hit": true,
                "predicate_hit": true,
                "causal_markers": [
                    "produces",
                    "corrosion",
                    "requires",
                    "moisture",
                    "oxygen"
                ],
                "mechanism_terms": [
                    "corrosion",
                    "requires",
                    "moisture",
                    "oxygen"
                ],
                "quality": 0.92
            },
            {
                "text": "Rusting occurs when iron is exposed to oxygen and water",
                "source_title": "Chemistry",
                "source_url": "https://example.edu/iron-rust",
                "source_domain": "example.edu",
                "evidence_score": 0.86,
                "relationship_score": 0.99,
                "relationship_types": [
                    "formation",
                    "condition"
                ],
                "subject_hit": true,
                "predicate_hit": true,
                "causal_markers": [
                    "occurs when",
                    "water",
                    "oxygen"
                ],
                "mechanism_terms": [
                    "occurs when",
                    "water",
                    "oxygen"
                ],
                "quality": 0.92
            },
            {
                "text": "Water helps the electrochemical corrosion reaction that leads to oxidation of iron.",
                "source_title": "Reference",
                "source_url": "https://reference.example.org/rust",
                "source_domain": "reference.example.org",
                "evidence_score": 0.79,
                "relationship_score": 0.8499999999999999,
                "relationship_types": [
                    "effect",
                    "mechanism",
                    "condition"
                ],
                "subject_hit": true,
                "predicate_hit": false,
                "causal_markers": [
                    "leads to",
                    "oxidation",
                    "corrosion",
                    "water"
                ],
                "mechanism_terms": [
                    "oxidation",
                    "corrosion",
                    "water"
                ],
                "quality": 0.79
            },
            {
                "text": "the corrosion process oxidizes iron.",
                "source_title": "Chemistry",
                "source_url": "https://example.edu/iron-rust",
                "source_domain": "example.edu",
                "evidence_score": 0.86,
                "relationship_score": 0.6699999999999999,
                "relationship_types": [
                    "mechanism"
                ],
                "subject_hit": true,
                "predicate_hit": false,
                "causal_markers": [
                    "oxidizes",
                    "corrosion"
                ],
                "mechanism_terms": [
                    "oxidizes",
                    "corrosion"
                ],
                "quality": 0.92
            }
        ],
        "consensus": {
            "status": "ANSWER_SUFFICIENT",
            "answer_sufficient": true,
            "score": 1,
            "claim_count": 4,
            "strong_relationship_claims": 4,
            "causal_support_claims": 3,
            "mechanism_support_claims": 3,
            "distinct_source_count": 3,
            "authoritative_source_count": 3,
            "average_source_quality": 0.8875,
            "policy": "answer sufficiency is independent from verified-LTM promotion"
        },
        "composer": {
            "used": true,
            "answer": "Iron rusts because iron undergoes oxidation/corrosion when oxygen and water or moisture are present. That process forms iron oxides that make up rust.",
            "selected_claims": [
                {
                    "text": "Iron corrosion requires moisture and oxygen and produces iron oxides commonly associated with rust.",
                    "source_title": "Materials",
                    "source_url": "https://example.gov/corrosion",
                    "source_domain": "example.gov",
                    "evidence_score": 0.88,
                    "relationship_score": 1,
                    "relationship_types": [
                        "effect",
                        "mechanism",
                        "condition"
                    ],
                    "subject_hit": true,
                    "predicate_hit": true,
                    "causal_markers": [
                        "produces",
                        "corrosion",
                        "requires",
                        "moisture",
                        "oxygen"
                    ],
                    "mechanism_terms": [
                        "corrosion",
                        "requires",
                        "moisture",
                        "oxygen"
                    ],
                    "quality": 0.92
                },
                {
                    "text": "Rusting occurs when iron is exposed to oxygen and water",
                    "source_title": "Chemistry",
                    "source_url": "https://example.edu/iron-rust",
                    "source_domain": "example.edu",
                    "evidence_score": 0.86,
                    "relationship_score": 0.99,
                    "relationship_types": [
                        "formation",
                        "condition"
                    ],
                    "subject_hit": true,
                    "predicate_hit": true,
                    "causal_markers": [
                        "occurs when",
                        "water",
                        "oxygen"
                    ],
                    "mechanism_terms": [
                        "occurs when",
                        "water",
                        "oxygen"
                    ],
                    "quality": 0.92
                },
                {
                    "text": "Water helps the electrochemical corrosion reaction that leads to oxidation of iron.",
                    "source_title": "Reference",
                    "source_url": "https://reference.example.org/rust",
                    "source_domain": "reference.example.org",
                    "evidence_score": 0.79,
                    "relationship_score": 0.8499999999999999,
                    "relationship_types": [
                        "effect",
                        "mechanism",
                        "condition"
                    ],
                    "subject_hit": true,
                    "predicate_hit": false,
                    "causal_markers": [
                        "leads to",
                        "oxidation",
                        "corrosion",
                        "water"
                    ],
                    "mechanism_terms": [
                        "oxidation",
                        "corrosion",
                        "water"
                    ],
                    "quality": 0.79
                }
            ],
            "mode": "evidence_bound_causal_template"
        },
        "answer_gate": {
            "allow_answer": true,
            "status": "GROUNDED_ANSWER_ALLOWED",
            "score": 1,
            "ltm_promotion_independent": true,
            "policy": "A grounded user answer may be allowed below the stricter verified-LTM consolidation threshold."
        }
    },
    "weak": {
        "claims": [],
        "consensus": {
            "status": "MORE_CAUSAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED",
            "answer_sufficient": false,
            "score": 0,
            "claim_count": 0,
            "strong_relationship_claims": 0,
            "causal_support_claims": 0,
            "mechanism_support_claims": 0,
            "distinct_source_count": 0,
            "authoritative_source_count": 0,
            "average_source_quality": 0,
            "policy": "answer sufficiency is independent from verified-LTM promotion"
        },
        "answer_gate": {
            "allow_answer": false,
            "status": "HOLD_ANSWER",
            "score": 0,
            "ltm_promotion_independent": true,
            "policy": "A grounded user answer may be allowed below the stricter verified-LTM consolidation threshold."
        }
    }
}